On October 14th HHS issued a regulatory notice and announced its decision to grant CMS permissive exclusion authority, creating a new enforcement consideration for providers participating in Federal programs.[1] The notice gives CMS exclusion authority previously delegated to the OIG, without removing OIG authority. The OIG has an existing procedural framework for its use of its permissive exclusion authority. The October 14th notice authorizes CMS’ new exclusion powers while establishing the formal legal mechanism but provides few details as to how it will be implemented.
While CMS is required to follow applicable policies, procedures and regulations, its enforcement efforts could follow a more expedited approach with less opportunity to challenge the exclusion. While HHS OIG exclusions typically result from lengthy fraud investigations, or False Claims Act settlements, a CMS exclusion, investigation and procedure, could be initiated from an audit finding of billing patterns found by a program integrity contractor. The MAC, CMS’s administrative contractor, reviews all claims, and identifies patterns of claims that could signal improper payment.
Under CMS’s regulatory authority, the remedies that could result from a CMS contractor’s determination that a billing pattern is indicative of fraud, are procedurally well defined and include recoupment, payment suspension, prepayment review or post payment overpayment determinations, revocation of billing privileges, or a referral to law enforcement. Even the remedies resulting from a UPIC auditor’s findings have limited application and are restricted in scope.[2] However, these audit findings may now serve another purpose; establishing the foundation for a CMS’ investigation to pursue an administrative exclusion proceeding. While a CMS contractor’s findings cannot trigger an exclusion, they could serve as part of an expedited investigation into billing activity that could lead to a CMS permissive exclusion.
The Medicare contractors’ decisions may result in the referral of cases to law enforcement to consider civil or criminal prosecution, but those findings are subject to five levels of administrative appeals and cannot trigger exclusion from participation in federal healthcare programs. Exclusion of a provider under the CMS permissive exclusion authority, has only three levels of appeals, and imposes far more significant harm to providers.[3] Exclusion is known as a death sentence, because it cuts off all revenue that would be received from federal health care programs. Using program integrity auditor’s findings to trigger and expedite a CMS permissive exclusion proceeding, denies providers the opportunity to pursue all appeal rights afforded them, prior to the loss of participation in federal healthcare programs.
Questions as to when provider billing activity triggers CMS invoking permissive exclusion are unclear. What will be the standard CMS will employ in its administrative exclusion process? How aggressively will CMS use this authority? What procedural differences in approaches can providers expect that differ from traditional OIG exclusion matters? Will CMS develop enforcement priorities distinct from the OIG?
Without knowing where or how CMS will seek to utilize this authority, providers must be more aggressive in their building of compliance programs, and in their defense against audits. The development of CMS’s grant of permissive exclusion authority, with its undefined process, can expect legal challenges.
Notes
[1] Statement of Delegation of Authority, 91 Fed. Reg. 65219 (October 14, 2026) (Document No, 2026-21001), issued by the Department of Health and Human Services, delegating permissive exclusion authority under Section 1128 of the Social Security Act, effective immediately, October 14, 2026. “Formalizing this delegation aligns investigative and enforcement responsibilities within a single operating division, reducing redundancy and improving program integrity outcomes.” The OIG retains permissive exclusion authority as well. It is unclear how this mechanism is to be effected given that the notice specifically states that, “excluded from this delegation is the authority to conduct hearings and to issue regulations.”
[2] Investigate potential fraud and abuse for CMS administrative action or referral to law enforcement;
[3] An OIG permissive exclusion has a minimum of 1 year exclusion for excessive charges, unnecessary services, or substandard care, submission of false charges. Section 1128(b)(6) of the Social Security Act and 42 USC Section 1320a-7(b)(6). The determination that the provider has provided medically unnecessary services is also subject to a minimum one year exclusion. 42 USC Section 1320c-5. For fraud or other prohibited activity, there is no minimum period. 42 USC Section 1320a-7(b)(8).
Reinstatement to participation in federal health care programs is not automatic. Providers must apply for reinstatement. Under 42 CFR section 1001.3002, expiration of the exclusion period is only one requirement for reinstatement. The OIG must also determine that there are reasonable assurances that the conduct underlying the exclusion has not recurred and will not recur, and that the other applicable reinstatement criteria have been met, including that there are no other grounds for exclusion.
If the OIG denies the provider’s application for reinstatement, the provider must wait an additional year for reconsideration, and that decision is not subject to administrative or judicial review.
____________________________________________
Sabrina Skeldon is the owner of Physician Practice Guidance, a consulting firm that provides revenue cycle services to small and medium-size practices. Her company focuses on audit and compliance for providers and their staff.
She is a healthcare attorney, certified medical coder, medical auditor and certified medical biller. She has over 20 years’ experience in the healthcare industry.